What is Film Noir is a question I am not sure I can fully answer, because I am not so sure I know what it is. While talking about this in class I was torn about whether or not Film Noir is a style or a genre, and I would have to say that it is both. When film noir was first introduced during the 1940's-1950's. According to Raymond Durgnat, film noir wasn't a genre, but he continued with that statement by saying, "it is not defined, as are the western and gangster genres, by conventions of setting and conflict but rather by the more subtle qualities of tone and mood. It is a film 'noir' as opposed to the possible variants of film 'gray or film 'off-white,'" (Schrader, 230). After I read this I could only help but to agree with what Durgnat was saying but as well continued to talk about this in class I felt conflicted, because I felt beforehand that it was a genre, but after reading the article by Schrader and listening to what everyone had to say in class, and really hearing about all of the numerous aspects of film noir, I decided that I believe that it is both a style and genre, and here is why.
Back in the 1940's-1950's when the beginning of these films labeled film noirs came out I believe that it was a genre of film because everything about a film noir film fit into the decade in which they were produced. From the way that these films were set to portray the lives of people who looked just like everyone in the audience. Some of the key things that were almost always included in these films were; a femme fatale character, a hardboiled man who was usually a detective or officer of some sort, plenty of crime from beginning to end, usually shot at night on the streets while raining or as if just rained, lots of shadowing for contrast and to show the vertical lines that were very common as well, urban type setting, many times the police are the bad guys and the detectives are the good guys, corruption of all sorts, shifting in alliances, moral ambiguity, an expendable character or two just to name a few. Overall these films were filmed to show what people we hiding and many times they were love stories as well, almost always involving the detective and the femme fatale. Overall these were and still are great films, but to our generation now they seem boring at times and just cheesy or funny. We are not able to take them as seriously as they were probably taken back then because we have a very hard time relating to the characters and often the story as well, which leads me into my next point.
Today when I look at the differences between authentic real film noir films and the ones that have been made in the last ten years or so, I cannot help but see an enormous difference. Nowadays these film noir-esque films are just plain unappealing to me. I am all for your traditional shoot-em-up blow-em-up film and some classic crime stories, but these films are just boring and hilarious. They are constantly poking fun at what was once the classic film noir genre, and now when they make these new versions of film noirs they fail miserably, which is why I would also classify this as a style because there is no way to remake these films to actually look like and portray the real film noir type film. You can throw in all of the same elements and it still is not a good interpretation because this generation cannot relate to the kind of dress they wear, how they talk, or even what they do, our world is just way too different now to ever go back to how it used to be in the 1940's-1950's.
Film noir is to me a genre and a style. Maybe that just sounds like I am copping out on this question but it truly is what I think, and who can really argue with that? Well I guess some can and thats okay we are all entitled to our own opinion and ideas.